Liverpool’s Quiet January Raises Major Defensive Questions

Liverpool’s lack of defensive reinforcements during the January transfer window has sparked significant debate around the club’s long-term planning and risk management.

Despite clear signs that defensive depth was becoming a concern, Liverpool chose not to strengthen immediately. Whether that decision reflects confidence in their current squad or hidden long-term planning remains uncertain.

Injury Crisis Leaves Liverpool Short at the Back

Liverpool entered the transfer window already aware of the need to strengthen defensively. Their failed attempt to sign Crystal Palace centre back Marc Guéhi during the summer highlighted the club’s intention to add reinforcements.

However, their defensive situation quickly worsened. Young signing Giovanni Leoni suffered a serious knee injury early in the season, ruling him out for the remainder of the campaign. The problems deepened further in January when Conor Bradley also sustained a season-ending knee injury.

The combination of these setbacks left Liverpool significantly reduced in defensive options at a crucial stage of the season.

Aging Stars and Contract Uncertainty Add to the Risk

Beyond injuries, Liverpool’s defensive group faces additional long-term concerns.

Virgil van Dijk remains one of the team’s most reliable players but is approaching 35 years of age. Meanwhile, both Andy Robertson and Ibrahima Konaté are set to become free agents at the end of the season, creating uncertainty over future squad stability.

The remaining defensive options also present challenges. Jeremie Frimpong has struggled with recurring injuries, while Milos Kerkez primarily operates as an attacking wingback. Joe Gomez has also dealt with multiple injury absences this season, further highlighting the lack of consistent depth.

Limited Backup Options Offer Little Immediate Support

Liverpool’s remaining defensive cover appears limited. Rhys Williams has spent recent seasons on loan in lower divisions and has not featured regularly for Liverpool’s first team in several years.

Similarly, Calvin Ramsay, once considered a promising talent, has endured multiple injury setbacks and has struggled to secure consistent playing time throughout his early career.

While Liverpool secured the future signing of highly rated defender Jérémy Jacquet from Rennes, the 20-year-old will not join until next season, leaving the current squad without additional reinforcement for the ongoing campaign.

Financial Gamble Could Impact European Ambitions

Liverpool’s decision not to strengthen defensively could carry significant financial consequences.

Failure to secure qualification for next season’s Champions League could cost the club tens of millions of euros in potential revenue. Additionally, an early exit from the current Champions League campaign would further reduce financial returns.

Given Liverpool’s heavy fixture schedule over the past 18 months, the risk of relying on a small defensive group continues to grow.

Squad Depth Remains Crucial During Demanding Schedule

Modern football requires strong squad rotation, particularly for clubs competing across multiple competitions. Liverpool have played an extremely high number of matches in both domestic and European competitions, placing significant physical demands on their players.

Van Dijk’s near-constant availability has been impressive, but maintaining such reliance on a small number of defenders presents long-term risks. Additional depth could provide valuable flexibility during demanding fixture periods.

Strategic Confidence or Missed Opportunity?

Liverpool’s inactivity during the transfer window may reflect strong internal confidence in their defensive structure. Statistically, the team remains among the league’s best in limiting opposition chances, suggesting their system continues to function effectively.

However, many observers question whether failing to add even short-term defensive cover represents an unnecessary gamble. With several months to prepare for the window, the absence of reinforcements has left the club exposed should further injuries occur.

Only the remainder of the season will determine whether Liverpool’s patience was part of a calculated long-term strategy or a missed opportunity to strengthen at a crucial moment.