Transfer Window Winners: Who Nailed It?

Manchester City

Once again, Manchester City used January with ruthless efficiency. Knowing reinforcements were needed to sustain multiple trophy pushes, Pep Guardiola’s side acted early and decisively.

The headline signing was Antoine Semenyo, who arrived from Bournemouth for an initial £62.5 million. With 20 league goals over the previous 18 months, the Ghana international immediately added variety to an attack overly dependent on Erling Haaland — and has already delivered four goals.

Defensive injuries then forced City back into the market, and the £20 million capture of Marc Guéhi from Crystal Palace looks excellent value. While his wages are high, securing an England international mid-season helped stabilise a depleted back line.

The sale of Oscar Bobb to Fulham for £27 million softened the financial outlay, making this another well-balanced January for City.

Aston Villa

Operating under strict UEFA settlement constraints, Aston Villa’s window was about precision rather than volume — and they delivered.

Replacing Donyell Malen with Tammy Abraham for a reduced fee was impressive, especially given Abraham’s suitability to Unai Emery’s system and willingness to take a wage cut. The move improved balance without breaking financial rules.

The urgent loan return of Douglas Luiz, with three midfield injuries hitting in rapid succession, was equally crucial. Villa moved quickly and decisively, ensuring squad stability at a critical point in the season.

Youth signings and the recall of Leon Bailey rounded out a window that addressed both present needs and long-term planning.

AFC Bournemouth

Losing Semenyo was unavoidable, but Bournemouth handled it intelligently. Allowing the winger to leave early gave them time to react, bringing in Brazilian prospect Rayan, who has already contributed.

The club also invested wisely in midfield with Alex Tóth, clearly planning ahead as interest grows in Alex Scott. Adding goalkeeper Christos Mandas on loan provides much-needed competition after a difficult spell for Djordje Petrovic.

This was a calm, controlled window that showed strong internal planning.

Paris Saint-Germain

PSG made just one signing, but context makes it a major win.

Securing Dro Fernández from Barcelona for around €8 million represents outstanding business. The teenage midfielder was one of La Masia’s brightest prospects, and PSG acted decisively before his release clause could rise.

Even if his immediate impact is limited, this was a long-term strategic strike at minimal cost.

Atlético Madrid

Atlético were among LaLiga’s most active sides, reshaping rather than overhauling.

Selling Conor Gallagher and Giacomo Raspadori brought in significant funds, which were reinvested smartly. Ademola Lookman adds pace and goal threat, while young midfielders Obed Vargas and Rodrigo Mendoza strengthen the future core.

This was pragmatic squad management rather than short-term panic.